Getting Comfortable With the Unknown: Why Being Okay with Uncertainty Is A Skill to Master During Divorce

Alex Beattie, Divorce Prep Coach & Founder

Oct 26

5 min read

You can do everything “right” - hire the right attorney, get your financial documents in order, build your support team, read every book, go to therapy - and you will still feel uncomfortable.

Feeling uncertain about your future during divorce doesn't mean you're doing something wrong, it just means you're getting through life.

That’s not a sign you under-prepared. It’s a sign you’re getting divorced.

Here’s the reframe I give every client: being prepared — emotionally, administratively, financially, practically — doesn’t mean you stop feeling uncomfortable. It means you’re equipped to handle the discomfort when it shows up. And it will show up.

Everything about divorce is triggering, no matter how ready you are, because divorce isn’t really a logistics problem. It’s the end of a future you assumed you knew.

→ Subscribe to The Divorce Planner newsletter and get divorce prep tips and tools delivered right to your inbox!

Why Divorce Feels So Destabilizing, Even When You Saw It Coming

When you got married, you made a quiet, mostly unconscious trade: you handed over a certain amount of not-knowing in exchange for an assumed future. Who you’d grow old with. What the holidays would look like. Whose family you’d be tied to. You stopped having to ask those questions, because you thought you already had the answer.

Divorce doesn’t just end a relationship, it returns all of that uncertainty to you at once. No wonder it’s disorienting (even when you’re the one who wanted out).

Maggie Jackson, journalist and author of Uncertain: The Wisdom and Wonder of Being Unsure, wrote about this in a 2024 New York Times Opinion piece, citing research on what psychologists call “intolerance of uncertainty,” the tendency to treat not-knowing as a threat rather than a fact of life. Researchers at Ohio State found that people who scored high on this trait were more likely to struggle with stress and anxiety during periods of major upheaval, while people who could tolerate uncertainty better adapted faster and recovered sooner.

Michel Dugas, a psychology professor at the University of Quebec in Outaouais and one of the field’s leading researchers, put it plainly: “Life is inherently uncertain, and if you have difficulty dealing with that, you will have difficulty dealing with life.”

Divorce is simply the moment that difficulty gets tested hardest. In a randomized controlled study Dugas led, people with generalized anxiety disorder who worked through sessions specifically designed to build their tolerance for uncertainty saw significant and sustained drops in depression and anxiety. And those gains held a full year.

The skill isn’t eliminating the unknown. It’s learning to function, even thrive, inside it.

The Nervous System Isn’t Broken — It’s Doing Its Job

That jittery, can’t-sit-still, bracing-for-the-next-blow feeling isn’t dysfunction. When your brain hits something unexpected — a lawyer’s email, a co-parenting curveball, a date on the calendar you didn’t choose — it registers a mismatch between what you expected and what’s actually happening. That mismatch triggers heightened attention, sharper focus, and a kind of forced mental flexibility.

In other words: discomfort is your brain updating its model of your life. It’s not pleasant, but it’s productive. The goal isn’t to make the discomfort go away. It’s to stop interpreting it as proof that something’s wrong.

What Actually Helps: Focus on What’s in Your Control

This is where surrender becomes a strategy, not a white flag.

Divorce will hand you a hundred things you cannot control — your ex’s behavior, the court’s timeline, how your kids process it, what people assume about you. Trying to manage all of it is a fast track to burnout. The work is sorting what’s yours to hold from what isn’t, and then actually letting go of the rest.

A few ways to practice that:

Name what’s actually yours to control. Your responses, your documentation, your boundaries, your self-care, your legal strategy. That’s it. Everything else is noise you’re allowed to put down.
Know when to respond, and when not to. Not every provocation, text, or legal maneuver requires an immediate reaction. Pausing before you respond is often the most powerful move available to you.
Set intentions, not scripts. Instead of trying to map out exactly how your post-divorce life will look, decide how you want to feel and who you want to be on the other side. That’s a direction, not an impossible ideal that requires life cooperate on your terms to achieve.
Build the muscle, not just the mindset. A gratitude practice, a grounding ritual, a support group — these aren’t extras. They’re what make tolerating uncertainty sustainable instead of just aspirational.

Discomfort Is Not the Same as Danger

One of the more useful shifts you can make is separating the feeling of uncertainty from the belief that something is going wrong. They’re not the same thing. Avoiding every hard conversation, every unresolved question, every moment that feels unsettled keeps you stuck playing defense. Learning to let a feeling come and go without acting on it, or going into panic mode, is what actually moves you forward.

This doesn’t mean forcing positivity or pretending the unknown doesn’t scare you. It means acknowledging the fear is normal, checking whether the story you’re telling yourself about it is even accurate, and treating the discomfort as information instead of a verdict. That awareness is everything.

The Skill Nobody Tells You You’re Building

Here’s what I want you to sit with: the version of you who gets through this — who can tolerate not knowing where you’ll live in a year, what your co-parenting relationship will look like, who you’ll be when the dust settles — is building a skill that will serve you long after the divorce is final. Resilience isn’t the absence of uncertainty. It’s the capacity to stay functional, even grounded, inside it.

You don’t have to eliminate the unknown to move through this well. You just have to stop treating your discomfort with it as evidence that you’re failing. You’re not failing. You’re doing the single hardest psychological work divorce requires — and it’s the same work that will make you unshakeable on the other side.

This Is One Of The Ideas On Emotional Preparation for Divorce That My Book Features

The Divorce Planner: 8 Weeks to Get Organized, Find Clarity, and Become Your Own Best Advocate (Jossey-Bass/Wiley) walks you through the emotional, financial, administrative, and practical sides of divorce. It publishes January 13, 2027, and is

available for preorder now on Amazon and Barnes & Noble.

Ready to Start Preparing?

Sign up for my free 4-email divorce prep series. I'll walk you through exactly what to do emotionally, financially, administratively, and practically— in four emails so you can move forward with confidence and clarity.

→ Sign up for my free 4-email divorce prep series

Not sure where to start?

Book a free 15-minute consultation with me and we'll talk through where you are and what makes sense for your situation.

→ Book a free 15-minute consultation